To Kill Or Not To Kill AC Odyssey Choice And Consequences

Navigating through Arkadia in Assassin's Creed Odyssey presents players with critical decision-making moments during the quest titled To Kill or Not to Kill. As players work alongside Myrrine and Brasidas to uncover Cultist activity, contrasting philosophies force a choice between aggressive action and tactical diplomatic restraint. Understanding how these story choices influence future encounters is key to securing smooth narrative outcomes.
Meeting Myrrine and Brasidas in Arkadia
The journey begins when players head to Arkadia to reunite with Myrrine and Brasidas near Tegea. Upon arrival, an unexpected ambush by a mercenary tests your immediate combat skills before reaching your main allies. After defeating the attacker, you must decide whether to grant mercy or eliminate the threat on the spot.
The Conflict Between Aggressive and Tactical Approaches
Once you locate Myrrine and Brasidas, the two allies express opposing strategies for tackling Lagos the Archon. Myrrine demands an immediate public assault by destroying agricultural silos and garrisons to weaken Lagos's hold. In contrast, Brasidas prefers a quiet investigation to uncover evidence and potentially free Lagos from Cult coercion.
How Prior Quest Decisions Impact Lagos
Your ability to spare Lagos in later missions depends heavily on your choices during earlier chapters such as Monger Down. Siding with Brasidas by killing The Monger in secret allows players to convince Lagos to abandon the Cult of Kosmos. However, if The Monger was killed publicly, Lagos will remain hostile, forcing a fatal confrontation regardless of your dialogue choices.
Long Term Consequences on the Narrative
Sparing Lagos yields vital clues necessary for exposing the Spartan King who operates as a Cultist. Furthermore, choosing the non-lethal, diplomatic path strengthens your bond with Brasidas and prevents unnecessary faction strife. Balancing these choices carefully ensures your protagonist maintains strong political leverage across the Peloponnesian war.